Why Your Zestimate Is Probably Off on Long Island (and What to Use Instead)

Why Your Zestimate Is Probably Off on Long Island | DeSimone Real Estate

Almost every seller we meet has already checked their Zestimate. It’s a reasonable first step. But if you’re about to make a decision worth hundreds of thousands of dollars, it helps to know how far off that number can be.

What Zillow says about its own accuracy

Zillow publishes its error rates. For homes that are not listed for sale, the nationwide median error is a little over 7%. That means half of all off-market estimates miss the eventual sale price by more than that, in one direction or the other. Once a home is listed, with photos and a list price for the algorithm to lean on, the error drops below 2%.

Until you list, your house is an off-market home. On a $700,000 house, a 7% miss is roughly $49,000.

Why Long Island is hard for an algorithm

  • Renovations don’t show up. A new kitchen, a finished basement or a second-story addition often isn’t in the public record until well after the work is done, if ever.
  • Blocks matter more than ZIP codes. South of Merrick Road versus north, flood zone versus not, a corner lot on a busy avenue versus a quiet mid-block: two homes a half mile apart can sell very differently.
  • School district and tax lines. Many Long Island ZIP codes are split across school districts with very different tax bills, which buyers weigh heavily.
  • Few true comps. In older neighborhoods with a mix of capes, high ranches and colonials, the algorithm may be comparing your home to houses that aren’t really like it.

What to use instead

A comparative market analysis from a local agent starts with the same public data, then adjusts for what the algorithm can’t see: condition, layout, updates, the specific block and what buyers are paying right now. It also gives you a range and a strategy, not just a number.

Use the online estimate as a conversation starter. Use a local analysis to make the decision.

Your Next Step

What is your home really worth?

Get a free, no-obligation analysis based on recent sales on your street.

Get Your Free Home Valuation

Thinking about selling? See our seller resources.